Web lists-archives.com

Re: Embarrassing security bug in systemd




On Wed 06 Dec 2017 at 22:52:17 +0100, Urs Thuermann wrote:

> Yesterday, my 10 years old son logged into my laptop running Debian
> jessie using his account, and curiously asked if he is allowed to try
> the /sbin/reboot command.  Knowing I have a Linux system as opposed to
> some crappy Win machine, I replied "sure, go ahead and try".  Seconds
> later I was completely shocked when the machine actually rebooted...
> 
> Of course, my son doesn't have any special privileges, no entry in
> /etc/sudoers, etc.  But then I see

He is privileged because he has physical access to the machine.

> 
>     $ ls -l /sbin/reboot
>     lrwxrwxrwx 1 root root 14 Apr  8  2017 /sbin/reboot -> /bin/systemctl
>     $ ls -l /bin/systemctl
>     -rwxr-xr-x 1 root root 538904 Apr  8  2017 /bin/systemctl
>     $ dpkg -S /bin/systemctl
>     systemd: /bin/systemctl
> 
> The /bin/systemctl binary is not suid root, so I assume[1] it
> communicates to systemd which then reboots the machine without
> checking what user the request comes from.
> 
> I wonder how can such a severe bug make it into a Debian stable
> distribution?  And is this just an insane default setting on Debian's
> side or is it yet another instance of brain-dead systemd behavior?

A user with physical access to the machine can press the ON/OFF switch
or pull the plug out or switch to a terminal and do CTL+ALT+DEL. Which
one of these actions is a bug in Debian?
 
> Searching the man pages I couldn't find a way to fix this.  How can
> that be stopped?

A cast-iron solution for stopping a user with physical access to a
machine from powering it off has been sought for ages.

-- 
Brian.