Re: Consensus Call: Do We Want to Require or Recommend DH; comments by 2019-06-16
- Date: Mon, 27 May 2019 14:34:38 +0000
- From: Scott Kitterman <debian@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Subject: Re: Consensus Call: Do We Want to Require or Recommend DH; comments by 2019-06-16
On May 27, 2019 11:50:38 AM UTC, Sam Hartman <hartmans@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
>>>>>> "Scott" == Scott Kitterman <debian@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> writes:
> Scott> If we want to make not using dh except in certain situations
> Scott> a bug, it seems like something for a policy should kind of
> Scott> item. We have an existing process for updating policy, so
> Scott> this should probably be kicked over there for further
> Scott> evaluation.
>So a discussion like this tends to serve as inputs to discussions in
>rest of the project including policy. However, I'd hope that delegates
>like the policy editors or the TC would be guided by project consensus.
>And If this consensus call stands, my next action as DPL will be to
>to various people who are impacted about next steps.
>The project is not well served by having each team rehash all the
>Absolutely, whoever takes this on on the policy front (TC or policy
>editors) should figure out how to say this in policy. Absolutely if
>they find factors we failed to consider globally they should come back
>to us. If they read the discussion and believe I made the wrong
>consensus call for that discussion, they should come back and say so.
>But no I think we as a community right here get to decide what's a bug
>if we want to, and I think it's reasonable for us to hold our delegates
>accountable for implementing that decision or having a good reason to
That's fine. I've no objection to the determination that there is rough consensus among the DD's that participate on debian-devel that packages should use dh.
My concern is that this is not sufficient to resolve the question of if a package buggy that does not do so. I'd like it also to be clear that because lintian flags something like this isn't enough to make a package buggy.
I think the policy process is the next step to implement this aspect of the discussion.